Main RWBY: Fairy Tales of Remnant

RWBY: Fairy Tales of Remnant

0 / 0
How much do you like this book?
What’s the quality of the file?
Download the book for quality assessment
What’s the quality of the downloaded files?
PDF, 4.43 MB
Download (pdf, 4.43 MB)

To post a review, please sign in or sign up
You can write a book review and share your experiences. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books you've read. Whether you've loved the book or not, if you give your honest and detailed thoughts then people will find new books that are right for them.

RWBY: Before the Dawn

PDF, 1.57 MB
0 / 0

RWBY: Before the Dawn

MOBI , 925 KB
0 / 0

Title Page
The Warrior in the Woods
The Man Who Stared at the Sun
The Shallow Sea
The Hunter’s Children
The Indecisive King (a.k.a. The King, the Crown, and the Widow)
The Grimm Child
The Judgment of Faunus
The Infinite Man
The Two Brothers
The Story of the Seasons
The Girl in the Tower
The Gift of the Moon
Ozpin’s Afterword
About the Author

Remnant has a very long history, and yet we do not know much
about its ancient past. We have many questions, and never all the
answers we would like. But we do have stories. Whether they’re true
stories passed down through the ages or myths defying time itself,
our stories help explain who we are and why we’re here. They give
us solace when we need it, advice if we seek it, and connections that
bind us together as one people. If you don’t believe in stories, if you
can’t accept their truths, then you will always seek and never find.
When I became headmaster of Beacon Academy, one of my first
goals was to introduce a deeper study of the stories that make up
the fabric of our world—after all, I am first and foremost a teacher.

The volume in your hands has been a pet project of mine for many
years. I have traveled around Remnant to collect these fairy tales,
myths, and fables from recent memory and distant times. I have
discovered in this lifelong pursuit that if you wish to fully appreciate a
story, you should consider its source and attempt to unravel and
understand the storyteller’s intentions. Why did they tell this story?
Why now? Yes, stories may be shared for entertainment alone;
however, they also can disguise lessons, moral guidance, important
historic records, moon-shattering revelations—and even dire
warnings of hidden dangers in the world and difficult trials yet to
It may seem self-serving to place this book at the core of a new
curriculum at the Huntsmen academies; however, it also has been
compiled with these academies especially in mind. Our students hail
from all over Remnant, from all four kingdoms and even so; me
outlying regions. Each one brings a unique perspective to their
studies—influenced by personal experiences as well as those lived
vicariously through others. I believe it is important and instructive to
provide a common frame of reference— representing our diverse

backgrounds and cultures—for us all to share. School is where
young Huntsmen in training will figure out the world and find their
place in it, but stories, too, have served this noble purpose since
long before the first academy was built.
Because an appreciation of history is vital to preparing for our
future, I have always found value in continuing and creating school
traditions at Beacon Academy. If this collection is embraced as a
cherished school tradition, I will be proud to have played some small
part in that legacy.
There are few things I can be certain of in this world, but I do
know that stories like those collected here will always endure and
illuminate. If we are fortunate, people will continue to tell our stories
long after we are gone, and remember us. Above all, it is always my
hope that you as students—and we as people—will take time to
listen to others’ stories, share our own, and hold in our hearts the
lessons we learn from both.
— Professor Ozpin

There was once a village on the edge of a lush forest, known far and
wide as the safest place in the land. The evil creatures of Grimm had
not attacked there since long before anyone could remember, and it
was said that the woods themselves protected the people from harm:
as long as no one dared to enter the charmed forest, it would keep
the monsters at bay.
The people went about their days with carefree spirits, and the
village gradually grew as more people arrived to live in peace. Over
time, the people grew complacent in their ways, taking their fortune
for granted and trusting they would always be safe and happy. The
village children began playing games inside the woods, though they
never ventured too far. After all, they’d never even seen a Grimm
outside a storybook.
One day, a boy was playing hide and seek with his friends in the
woods. He ventured farther inside than ever before, farther than
anyone would ever think to look for him. He waited and waited, alone
in the gloomy forest. As night fell, the boy heard the woods come
alive with the sounds of flapping wings, skittering insects, and

rustling leaves. But he had never been afraid of the dark before, and
he had always been curious about the forest, so instead of returning
home to a hot meal and a warm fire, he wandered deeper into the
The boy soon found his way into a moonlit clearing, and there
something found him. He first saw its four glowing red eyes, then the
stark white of its long, sharp, curved tusks. This was the largest
creature the boy had ever seen, and its pitch-black hair was
seemingly made of the night itself.
He screamed! The boy couldn’t help it, for he had never seen
anything like the Grimm. For the first time in his life, he knew fear,
and he felt sure he was about to die.
The creature whirled on him, fixed the boy in its burning gaze,
and charged. The boy froze, throwing his arms up in front of him and
squeezing his eyes shut. But then, as he braced for the worst,
something shoved him aside. He tumbled away, through loose dirt,
stones, and leaves. And when he looked up he saw a tall, fair
woman in a flowing black cape facing off against the Grimm. She
gripped a long-handled billhook with both hands.
The boy was stunned to see the boar-like Grimm turn to run
away from her. The woman charged after it, her bladed staff spinning
so fast that it blurred.
Just before she caught up to the Grimm, the woman planted the
butt end of the weapon into the earth and vaulted feet-first into the
air. As she soared over the creature, she turned in midair, sweeping
the hooked blade down and slicing through the Grimm. It squealed
and split in two. When the woman landed, she pivoted to face the
Grimm again, but the broken pieces only puffed into thick black
smoke and floated away. She spun the billhook once more and
holstered it on her back.
“Go home. You never saw me,” she told the boy, turning to leave.
The boy jumped up. “Wait!” he said. His ankle was sprained, but
he hobbled after the woman, grimacing. She paused and looked
back, and that was the first time he truly saw her. She was as
beautiful as she was fierce.

Up close, he saw her black cloak was threadbare, its hem
tattered, tears throughout it mended with fraying red thread. Her
loose gray blouse might have been white once, and her leggings
were covered in mismatched patches. Her hair was almost as dark
as the Grimm’s, white hairs standing out as brightly as bone. The
metal hook on her weapon was chipped and a crack was beginning
to split the long wooden handle.
“Thank you,” he said simply.
She nodded and continued to move away.
“At least tell me your name!” he called after her. But she
disappeared into the trees.
The boy limped home. He didn’t tell anyone about the warrior
woman who had saved him, but he described the terrible monster he
had narrowly escaped. Those who believed him took his safe return
as proof that the woods protected them, and they continued living as
they had. But the boy had seen the truth, so he watched the woods
with caution, always remembering the woman. And he wondered:
who was she, and why had she saved him? Was it she that kept the
whole village safe?
A year later, the boy returned to the clearing in the woods, and
then he dared to go beyond it. Even during the day it was dark amid
the trees, and after some time he realized he was being followed. A
sense of dread overcame him, and when he looked over his
shoulder, he saw two bright yellow eyes flaring in the shadows. He
drew a dagger from his belt and only faltered when the creature
crashed through the trees and howled before him.
This Grimm had a gruesome, bony mask and it was sharp all
over: sharp teeth, sharp spikes, sharp claws. It bounded toward him
on four massive paws, its hind legs built for speed and power. The
boy raised his dagger, but it was almost as useless as if he had been
unarmed. He didn’t cry out or try to run away—he was frozen in
place by fear.
Just then, he saw the woman drop from a tree onto the creature’s
back and hack at its neck with her billhook. Its handle was shorter
now, and the boy saw she carried a sharpened stake made from its
other, broken half.

When the Grimm tried to shake her off, she jammed the stake
into one of its eyes. Then she jumped off and watched as the
terrible, dark wolf toppled backward and dissolved into a cloud of
mist. She retrieved the stake, its tip steaming.
“Thank you,” the boy said, finding his voice. She turned to him.
“You again?” She shook her head and walked off.
The boy felt an unexpected rush of joy. “You remember me?”
“I remember everyone I’ve saved. And everyone I didn’t.” She
paused to look at him. “I see you didn’t learn your lesson about
coming into my woods.”
He held up the dagger. “I came prepared.”
Her laugh was not unkind. “So you’re a slow learner. Don’t come
back. Really.”
“I came looking for you,” he admitted.
She narrowed her eyes. “I don’t train people to fight anymore.”
“It’s not that. I brought you something.” The boy pulled off his
backpack and held it out to her. She hesitated before coming closer
to take it. She wasn’t as tall as she had seemed before, and there
were more white strands in her hair. But she was still proud and
strong, and even more beautiful than he remembered.
“What’s this?” she said as she pulled out a bundle wrapped in
dark green cloth. Inside the bundle, there were three blouses like her
own, two leggings, a black skirt, new boots, and a short, hooded
green cloak.
“New clothes,” he said. “Well, not new really. They were my
Her brief smile faded. “Did she … die?” the warrior asked.
The boy shook his head. “No, she’s fine!” he said. “She doesn’t
wear these anymore. She told me to donate them to someone who
needs them, and that’s what I’m doing.”
The warrior said, “I need nothing. And I can’t accept these,
“Why not? It’s the least I can do.”
“The least you can do is leave and never come back.”
“Please,” he said.

“All right, if it will make you leave me alone.” She wrapped up the
clothes, nodded at him, and walked away with his gift. “Next time you
enter the woods, you’re on your own.”
When the boy returned the following year, he was now a young
man. He moved quietly through the trees—almost as quietly as the
warrior woman—so he avoided any encounters with Grimm until he
had nearly reached the center of the forest. Leaves rustled over his
head as he paused to refresh himself in a shallow stream. Then he
looked up to see three oversized, fearsome black owls fixing him in
their deadly stare. They spread their wings, revealing razor-sharp
feathers and deadly talons.
The boy drew a long, thin sword, which he had forged himself
under the dubious eye of the village blacksmith, who wondered why
anyone would hunt with such a weapon when they could use a bow
and arrow or a spear. But the boy had crafted his sword with a
special purpose: to fight the hate-filled monsters from his
The savage bird-creatures dived at him, attacking with claws and
thundering away with their powerful wings. While he had hoped for
the warrior woman to appear, he did not expect it, and indeed she
did not come to save him. It was a long, clumsy, bloody battle, but
eventually the young man prevailed over two of the beasts. The third
swooped at him. Exhausted, he couldn’t bring up his sword in time—
Then a brilliant white light flooded the woods. He shielded his
eyes, and when the brightness faded, the Grimm was gone. A
moment later, the warrior woman appeared.
“What was that light? Where did it go?” he asked.
“You’re developing a bad habit,” she said.
He sheathed his sword and grinned. Was it just wishful thinking,
or was she happy to see him? She was wearing a clean white blouse
with a black skirt, sturdy boots, and a dark green cloak. Her hair was
pulled back into a ponytail. She held her shortened billhook, the end
of the broken handle crisscrossed with red ribbon.
“I knew you’d come to my rescue,” he said. “Thank you.”
“For what? I didn’t do anything.”
“Didn’t you?” He raised an eyebrow. “You were nearby at least.”

“I told you I wouldn’t save you this time,” she said. “Fortunately
you did pretty well on your own.”
“Then thanks for watching over me yet again. Not just today, but
always. Thanks for protecting all of us, for all these years, without
anyone knowing you’re responsible for our safety.”
“Why do you keep coming back here?”
He looked into her eyes.
She snorted. “Don’t tell me you’re in love with me.”
He blushed. “I brought you food.” He offered his backpack to her
once more.
“I have food.” But she opened the bag and pulled out parcel after
parcel. There was honey cake, and strawberry tart, and sweet
biscuits. When she unwrapped a stack of fresh-baked cookies, her
expression lightened, and her happiness made him happy. She
popped a cookie into her mouth and chewed.
“I haven’t had anything like this in a long time.” She stared at the
delicacies spread out around her. He got up to leave as she began
her feast.
“Don’t come back,” she mumbled after him, her mouth full.
“I know,” he said.
But of course the young man came back, a year to the day later.
This time he made it all the way to the center of the woods, where he
found a homely hut and the warrior woman waiting for him outside it,
at a small table with two seats, two cups, and a steaming pot of tea.
“Now what do you want?” she asked.
“I was just in the neighborhood and thought I would stop by.
Didn’t see any Grimm this time.”
“I cleared them out of the area this morning.” She stretched.
“They’ll be back. They always come back. But we have some time.”
“Some time is all we need.” He set down the weapons he carried:
a new, better-fashioned sword and a gleaming new billhook with a
long, sturdy handle. He sat down across from her as she poured tea
into his cup.
“Two weapons?” she observed. “You came overprepared this

“I made the billhook for you.” He glanced at the one leaning up
against her door, rope wrapped around the base of the curved blade
to hold it to the handle. “That one has seen better days.”
“So have I.” She sipped her tea. “Why do you keep coming here
and giving me gifts every year?”
“You know,” he said. “To thank you.”
“You’ve already done that. No need to keep coming back for
“You’ve saved me each time we’ve met, and maybe more times
besides. And I know that you’ve saved all of us.”
She didn’t say a word.
He put down his teacup. “May I ask you a question?”
“Ah.” She sighed. “Go ahead and ask. I don’t promise an
“Nothing is promised in life,” he said.
“You’ve grown up a good deal since I first saw you.”
“I had to,” he said. “My question is: Why? Why do you live in the
woods alone? Why do you risk your life to save strangers? Why do
you protect the village? Why this village?”
“That’s five questions.” Her shoulders slumped. “But they all have
the same answer.”
Her voice was soft and sad when she replied. “I live here alone
because I am alone. And as a general rule, I don’t like people. Most
of my own people were killed long ago. My family, everyone I’ve ever
known is dead, and if there are other survivors like me, they’re
scattered all over Remnant.”
“Killed by Grimm?”
She scowled. “Murdered by other Humans.”
“Oh.” The young man grasped his cup with both hands, so the
tea would warm them. “But then why do you protect others?”
She looked at him steadily. “Because I can. Because no one else
will.” She smiled. “And because some people are good, like you. And
that gives me hope.”
She stood, hefted the billhook appreciatively, and walked toward
her hut.
“Finish your tea and then go,” she said.

But he had more to say. “You’ve spent all these years looking
after us,” he explained. “I thought maybe it would be nice if someone
looked after you for a change.” He stood to leave. “Because that’s
what I can do. Because no one else will.”
She smiled. “Don’t come back,” she said. But they both knew, by
now, that he would.
Over the next year, the village expanded right up to the perimeter
of the forest. Then the people went into the forest and chopped down
trees to build more houses, so the village grew while the forest
shrank. That was the year that the Grimm returned, attacking with
more and more frequency and ferocity. People said that the village
had broken its promise with the woods. Others suggested that with
too many people, there were too many emotions, and that had
brought the Grimm back.
But one man knew that the Grimm had always been there, out of
sight and out of mind, because the village was protected by a brave
warrior. He waited until the appointed day for his annual visit, worried
about what he might discover.
It was a nonstop fight to get to her home; he dispatched wave
after wave of Grimm. He paused at each place that he had
encountered the woman on his previous visits and waited, but she
never appeared. Finally he reached her hut. The bladed staff he had
made her was waiting by the entrance, as though she had just
stepped away for a moment. But the door was missing, torn off its
hinges. The interior was wrecked, whether by man or beast he
couldn’t tell. It had been abandoned for a while. The warrior woman
was gone.

He shouldered the warrior’s billhook and fought his way back to
the village. Soon, the people would have to leave and settle
somewhere else—without their guardian, the woods had become too
dangerous. But until that day, he would do his best to protect them in
her place. Because he could. Because no one else would.
Back in the village, around a fire that couldn’t quite warm him, he
told the people the woman’s story, so they would always know who
they had to thank for the many good days they’d enjoyed.
“I wish I could have been there for her,” he said slowly, “the way
she was there for us.” If she was dead, she had died alone.

“Why did you keep going back there, year after year?” a village
woman asked him. “Because she saved you?”
“For that reason, and for many more,” he said slowly. “But I
believe she knew the deepest reason of all.”
The group waited. He gazed into the fire.
“I fell in love with her the moment I saw her silver eyes.”

More than a few Huntsmen and Huntresses cite this story as one of
their childhood favorites, myself included. There are some more
fantastical versions of the tale, embellishments which add nothing to
its deeper meaning and don’t bear repeating—though the least
believable element is perhaps the notion that any child could grow
up in Remnant without knowing of Grimm, or even encountering
them from a very young age. In fact, “The Warrior in the Woods” is
often used as a cautionary tale, intended to discourage children from
wandering too far from home on their own, or from relying too much
on others to save them. But the most enduring, and I think the most
inspiring, aspect of this story is one which many have taken to heart:
If you can help others, it is your responsibility to do so. Whether that
means fighting evil singlehandedly or baking cookies (for kindness
can be as rare as silver eyes) is up to the reader to decide for
themselves. From each according to their own abilities.

A farmer irrigating his fields at midday exclaimed loudly about the
heat. The sun, passing overhead, happened to hear the complaint
and replied, “Just as you have your job, I have mine. Rather than
criticize, you should thank me! For without my efforts, all of yours
would be for naught.”
“I work hard to feed my family, and this unbearable heat makes
me work even harder.” The farmer mopped his sweaty brow with his
kerchief. “My crops keep drying up, though I water and tend to them
every day. Perhaps you are too good at your job. Instead of me
doing more, perhaps you could do a little less.”
The sun flared at the suggestion, and the farmer and his crops
wilted under the intense heat. The sun began to move on, muttering,
“People should accept responsibility for their own failure.” But the
farmer called after him.
“I’m sorry! You’re right. I couldn’t do my work without you.”
The sun, mollified, cooled off. The farmer sighed with relief.
“Thank you,” he said.

“That’s all I wanted to hear. Everyone is always so quick to blame
me, whether it’s hot or cloudy, but no one ever bothers to show some
appreciation for what I do. They won’t even look at me! It really burns
me up.”
“That’s terrible. People should show you more respect and
The sun brightened cheerfully.
The farmer squinted. “We are both proud of our jobs and too
stubborn to change our ways, but I have an idea to make things
better for both of us. How about a race? If I win, you will take special
care to give my plants just the right amount of light and warmth for
optimal growth, for as long as they are tended by my children and
my children’s children.”

“And if I win?”
“I and my children and my children’s children will adore you and
encourage others to celebrate your magnificence.”
“I like this idea,” said the sun. “But racing is so exhausting, and
we’ve both been up since dawn. Since you suggested a competition,
perhaps I could choose the nature of it?”
The farmer thought carefully. “That seems fair. What will it be?”
The sun smiled. “A staring contest.”
“Oh.” The farmer hesitated. “Very well.”
“Let us begin.”
The farmer slowly lifted his face toward the sun, eyes wide open,
and the sun fixed its gaze on him. As the hours passed, stinging
sweat trickled into the farmer’s eyes, but he never flinched and never
Evening arrived, though it was still bright as day. The farmer’s
wife came looking for him and was astonished to find him competing
with the sun. She begged her husband to come home to dinner. He
“Look how upset you’ve made her,” the sun said. But the farmer
didn’t glance away.
“Nice try,” said the farmer’s wife. She gave her husband some
food and then took over his work in the fields.
Days passed, and the sun stayed in place, watching the farmer
as the farmer watched him. The farmer’s wife and children continued
watering the fields around him and their crops flourished from the
sun’s attention.
“I bet watching your children so hard at work would fill you with
pride,” the sun said.
“I am proud whether I can admire them or not.” Tears trickled
down the farmer’s cheeks, but he never glanced away and never
Weeks passed, and while the farmer’s fields thrived and the
surrounding region grew lush and green, other crops around the
world were dying, deprived of light. For the first time, the sun was
failing to do his job.

“Your farm has never been more prosperous!” the sun said. “Look
around you and marvel at its beauty.”
“I cannot,” the farmer said sadly. “I’ll just take your word for it.”
Finally, the tug of duty became too great, so the sun relented. He
blinked. “You win. I must carry on with my responsibilities.”
The farmer closed his eyes and covered them with a hand.
“Remember our agreement,” he said wearily.
“As promised, from now on, your crops will grow better than
anyone else’s, for as long as you and your people work hard and
take care of the land.”
“Thank you,” the farmer said, and this time he meant it.
As the sun began to set, he called back to the man. “I knew you
would have beaten me in a race, because I’ve seen you run faster
than the wind.”
The farmer shrugged. His Semblance allowed him to cross great
distances in the blink of an eye. It was useful in managing his
expansive farmlands, and whenever he could get away he loved to
travel all over Sanus to take in the continent’s wonders.
“That’s why I chose a staring contest,” the sun said. “Most people
cannot bear to look at me for more than a few seconds, so I was
sure you would lose right away. I have to know: How did you outlast
The man opened his vacant eyes and said, “I’ll tell you. From the
start of our competition, I was immediately blinded by your splendor.
With the damage already done, I kept my eyes open and faked it.”
The sun was angry that he had been tricked after all. But since
the farmer had lost so much—he could no longer see his beautiful
family, look proudly upon his farm, or race around exploring the
world—the sun moved on and honored their bargain.
One can only succeed when one is willing to sacrifice something

The origins of “The Man Who Stared at the Sun,” often called “The
Farmer and the Sun,” trace back to Vacuo, which of course was
once much more verdant than it is now. One variation on the tale
makes the farmer a blind man from the beginning, who tricks the
unwitting sun into entering a staring contest with him and easily wins;
this version has grown in popularity in Vacuo over the years, perhaps
reflecting the increased value of ingenuity to survive there. The way
the story is told may reveal much about the character of the person
telling it. Personally, I think the original version more closely
represents the hardy spirit of Vacuo, as the farmer stubbornly makes
the most of a bad situation. I am particularly fond of yet another
alternate take which offers a simpler, yet classically Vacuan twist on
the moral lesson: Don’t stare at the sun.

Long ago, before the fish had scales, before the birds had feathers,
and before the turtles had shells, when our god still walked and
crawled and slithered the earth, there were only Humans and
animals. (And Grimm. There have always been Grimm. There will
always be Grimm. But those creatures don’t figure in this story, so
just put them out of your mind, if you can.) The Humans lived
everywhere across Remnant excepting one small island, which our
sagacious, perspicacious, and most veracious god protected as a
haven for animals of all kinds.
As I hope you will recall, little one, the God of Animals takes
whatever form they like, whenever they like. They might be a strongheaded ram in one moment, and a skittering skink the next. Or
perhaps a broad-winged roc and then—as quick as a blink—a fierce
lion! Or, of course, any combination of any beasts under the sun, so
that they might have the head of a lamb, the body of a boar, the feet
of an elephant, and the wings of a wyvern. Their form shifts like a

changing thought, like flowing water, and if you look away—
remember, you should never look away from a god—you might miss
a beautiful blending that will never exist again.
Anyway. The God of Animals cantered and burrowed and
fluttered over the earth, admiring the creatures they had gathered on
this island and seeing that it was good. But the thing about
sagacious, perspicacious, and indeed veracious beings is that they
tend to get bored. And despite the excellent company of every kind
of animal, the god was curious about the only living thing absent
from the island—Humans. (No, not Grimm. Grimm are not alive in
the usual sense, nor does anyone want them. Please do put them
out of your mind, if you can.)
The God of Animals was fascinated with Humans, with their
ability to create things and to adapt to new situations and indeed to
change themselves almost as readily as the god could change their

But they also knew that Humans could be ruinous. Inviting Humans
to the island would be inviting trouble. No, it could not be. It would
never happen!
But the god was stubborn as a bull and crafty as a fox. Perhaps if
they found some very special Humans, ones who truly belonged on
the island, they could find a way to keep them there.
The God of Animals toured the continents of Remnant, visiting
every town and village of every kingdom, searching for those who
were perhaps just a little more than Human. Their eagle eyes sought
out the misfits and the outcasts who didn’t fit in where they were,
perhaps because they truly belonged somewhere else. And the god,
who could change their shape at will, assumed the awkward form of

Humans and walked the earth in their constricting clothes and
cramped shoes. When they found someone they wanted, they
whispered and planted one thought: Leave. Sail to the Shallow Sea.
It’s where you’re meant to be.
The God of Animals arranged for a great ark to make its way
across the oceans of Remnant. It docked at each kingdom and
picked up those Humans who longed for a change, or felt they
weren’t welcome among their own people, or had never felt
comfortable in their own skin. The ark loaded with these chosen
people sailed down, down, down to the Shallow Sea. And when it
reached the sea, it sailed around the island. The people grew
uneasy as they observed a harsh desert stretching from the coast as
far as the eye could see. They became unsettled as they took note
of the diverse wildlife along the shores.
(Were you wondering whether there were any Grimm on the
island in those days? As I’ve told you, Grimm do not figure into this
story, and I wish you would clear them from your mind.)
“This barren land is no place for us. We should turn back,” the
people said.
“I want you to see all of this land for what it is,” the God of
Animals said. “Trust me: You do belong here, if you are willing to
work for it.”
But then the ark rounded the cape to the southern shore, and the
Humans saw that there it was a paradise. The god leapt from the ark
and splashed into the water, which reached only to their waist. As
they stood there, they shed their Human form and took on the horns
of a ram, the tail of a monkey, the scales of a serpent.
“This can be your home, if you want it. You’re right, this is no
place for mere Humans—but you are no mere Humans. If you jump
from the boat and join me, you will see.”
The people with the strongest faith leapt from the boat
immediately and splashed in the shallow water toward the shore.
Those who stayed behind on the boat watched their brethren
transform before their eyes, each of them acquiring an animal trait:
ram horns, rabbit ears, cat ears, monkey tails, and more. By the time

they reached land, they were something new to Remnant—both
Human and animal at the same time.
“This land is no less hospitable than where we came from,” the
people on the beach said. “But here at least we have control of our
fates, free from the influence of others.”
More people on the boat, emboldened by the miracle they had
witnessed, jumped next into the water. They followed the others to
the shore of the island, each of them changing in the process, taking
on animal features of their own: leopard spots, lion manes, lamb
ears, pig snouts, crocodile scales, and more.
The final group of people on the boat hung on to the railing.
“What have you done to them?” they cried.
“They didn’t do anything to us,” the people on the shore called.
“The water hasn’t changed us. It has washed away the lies to reveal
what we’ve always been, just under the surface. Our old forms were
just a shallow disguise. This is who we are.”
A few dozen more people on the boat were convinced. They
dropped into the ocean, and though they transformed more slowly,
by the time they stepped out of the water, they, too, had become
their true selves and were welcomed onto the island.
But the small group remaining on the boat were too horrified or
afraid to take the leap of faith. “What kind of monster are you?” they
shouted at the God of Animals.
The god’s heart hardened against these people. “You were my
chosen ones, but you have disappointed me. You may stay on the
boat and return to your homes. There is no place for you here.” And
with that, the ocean current swept the ark away with the Humans.
“The sea revealed the shallowness of their thoughts,” the god
told their chosen people. “Without them ever stepping off the boat.”
From that moment on, there have been animals, Humans, and
Faunus. And the descendants of the Humans who turned away from
our god’s great gift have always carried envy in their hearts. To this
day, they resent us for reminding them of what they are not and what
they never can be.

Although this fable once was among the most common stories told
to Faunus children, it has never been written down before its
appearance here, not by Faunus and certainly not by Humans. I
gave serious consideration as to whether to include it, but as it
provides a lovely, and I think necessary, counterpoint to “The
Judgment of Faunus,” also in this collection, I felt it important to
record. I humbly request forgiveness if I am perceived to have
overstepped myself in any way; know simply that I deeply respect
the rich history of Faunus and wish to represent them among stories
of Remnant. As Faunus stories are generally passed down from
generation to generation, few outsiders have ever heard them, and
that does everyone a disservice. We must be exposed to the stories
of people from all kingdoms and cultures, Humans and Faunus alike,
if we hope to make progress in understanding one another.
That said, we must take care not to characterize “The Shallow
Sea” as a mere story, for it is so much more to Faunus. I do not wish
to subject it to the literary critiques I might bring to another tale. This
story is a key to Faunus’s identity, and therein lies its chief value.
However, I will note that many Humans and even Faunus view this
story as mere fantasy, a fanciful creation myth—and even, perhaps,
a dangerous one. In the aftermath of the Great War, when Faunus

settled on Menagerie, the story of a magical island made just for
them has become tinged with bittersweet irony. Consequently, the
story has fallen out of favor and I understand it is rarely spoken
these days. This, too, influenced my decision to record it before it is
lost to posterity.
Here I will remind you that this story—dare I say every story ever
told—may still hold a kernel of truth, even if the plot details are
contrived. Whatever the criticisms laid upon “The Shallow Sea,” in
my opinion it still holds deep truths about Humans and Faunus that
everyone should take the time to consider.

There was once a hunter who had four children: two daughters and
two sons. The family lived in a small village deep in the swamps of
the kingdom of Mistral, swamps that were also home to fearsome
Creatures of Grimm such as the great Lagartodiles, fierce Grendels,
poisonous Long Tongues, and tricky Whisps. In those days, if
Humans could not defend themselves from Grimm—and they rarely
could—they would flee their homes and rebuild what they could of
their lives elsewhere. Thus, they left more and more of their land to
the monsters … and sooner or later the monsters always followed.
However, this hunter was different from all others. Each day,
while the other men and women of the village chased swamp
animals for food, this hunter chased Grimm. In the evenings, when
the men and women came home with meat for their families, this
hunter always returned empty-handed. When a Creature of Grimm is
killed, its body fades like a bad dream, and you would not want to eat
one even if you could.
The hunter and his children did not starve because the other
villagers shared their food in gratitude for his protection. While the

hunter’s family ate dinner, he told his two daughters and two sons
about the Grimm he had fought that day and how he had killed them.
Often his children asked, “But why are you the only one who hunts
The hunter had several answers for this question, depending on
his mood.
“Because my Aura is stronger than anyone else’s in the village,”
the hunter might answer. Which would prompt a lecture about how a
strong Aura was not enough on its own, if one did not know how to
use it to shield oneself from harm or activate a Semblance.
“Because my Semblance tells me when Grimm are near,” the
hunter might answer. This would prompt a lively discussion about
who in the family had the most useful Semblance: the older sister,
whose Semblance always led her toward what she needed most?
The older brother, whose Semblance linked people’s Auras as long
as they were in physical contact? The younger sister, whose
Semblance calmed any Human or animal? Or the younger brother,
whose Semblance allowed him to hide in plain sight?
“Because I hate the Grimm for killing your mother,” the hunter
might answer. “And I hate myself for not being there when she died.”
Dinner conversation was silent on those nights until one child would
ask softly, “Tell us about Mother again.” And soon they would be
sharing their favorite memories of her, such as her sharp sense of
humor, her beautiful singing voice, and her gentle but firm hand in
guiding their combat training.
One day, the hunter did not come home from the swamp. The
men and women of the village, with fear and pity in their hearts, told
the hunter’s children that he had died defending them from Grimm.
The hunter’s two daughters and two sons grieved that night, but in
the morning they sat down to decide what to do.
“We must stay here and defend our home as Father did,” the
older daughter said.
The older brother said, “What about all the other people out there
in need? We must try to help them, too.”
“No,” said the younger sister. “We need to study the Grimm, so
we can figure out better ways to protect against them.”

The younger brother shook his head. “We should seek adventure
on our own. We know how to fight, but we only put ourselves at risk
when we try to protect others.”
The hunter’s children loved one another too much to argue.
Recognizing that they were at an impasse, they decided to split up
and pursue their own destinies in their own ways.
The older sister bid her siblings farewell as they departed the
following morning. She pledged her services to the village, but the
people were upset by the death of the hunter and the Grimm began
attacking almost daily. The older sister saved many lives, but the
number of Grimm grew while the number of villagers dwindled. Soon
many left in search of new homes.
The older brother journeyed to the next village over in search of
other hunters like his father, but that village was gone—destroyed by
Grimm. This was also the fate of the next three villages he visited.
The fifth village he found under siege. The older brother convinced
the villagers to link themselves together with a rope, and supported
by their combined Auras, he defeated the Grimm. The villagers
welcomed the newcomer as their champion and begged him to stay.
The younger sister ventured into the woods near her village and
built a structure high on a tree branch from which she could observe
Grimm safely. Whenever one came near, she calmed herself enough
to avoid its attention while she made careful notes and sketches. But
studying the Grimm in this passive state did not provide useful
information about their strength and abilities in combat. One day, a
large group of Grimm stormed past in a frenzy. She followed the
pack toward whatever was drawing them deeper into the woods.
The younger brother, for all his bravado and independence, had
never been in the forest alone before, and he became lost almost as
soon as he left home. Though he also could hide from Grimm by
closing his eyes, they still sensed his presence—and he was unable
to see where he was going. He wandered among the trees for days,
feeling frustrated and foolish and very sorry for himself. Eventually
the Grimm trapped him in a clearing, where he huddled on the
ground, eyes shut, as they circled.

Suddenly an overwhelming sense of calm came over him and he
dared to open his eyes. The nearby Grimm had lost interest in him
and began to wander off. Then he heard a familiar voice.
“How’s your adventure going, Brother?” the younger sister said.
When he saw her, he jumped up and they embraced warmly.
They had never been apart for more than half a day before going
their separate ways.
The brother admitted that he had gotten lost in the forest and had
been too afraid to fight the Grimm alone. His sister related that she
had been studying the Grimm when they suddenly went on the
move. They both knew what that meant: Someone else was going to
be in trouble soon.
“We have to help them,” they agreed. No longer drawn to the
brother, the creatures headed off toward a larger target with the
reunited siblings following close behind.
A short distance away, the older sister was using her Semblance
to lead her village toward what she assumed was a new and safer
home. Ever vigilant, she was the first to spot the group of Grimm as
they burst from the forest.
Her heart sank as she fought the dark creatures. Perhaps one or
two of her people would manage to escape. But then the Grimm
began falling—from behind. She whooped with joy when she saw
her younger sister and younger brother fighting their way toward her.
The three siblings stood together, a short line of defense between
the Grimm and the villagers. They held off the nightmare beasts, but
they would never defeat them all. And their Auras were weakening.
Just as they feared all was lost, the older sister felt a hand on her
shoulder and her Aura grew stronger. She turned and saw the older
brother at her side. Behind him was a long line of people all tied to a
rope at their waists.
“Miss me?” he asked.
The four siblings grinned at one another and clasped hands,
renewing their strength. The older brother passed the rope to his
siblings, and they looped it about their waists. Linked to the Auras of
dozens of people, they were able to destroy the small army of

When the fight was won and the night ended, the siblings at last
had a chance to catch up.
“I am sorry for being stubborn. There were too many Grimm for
me to fight alone. Without you, I lost my direction,” said the older
sister. “No wonder that my Semblance led me right back to my family
—and my true home.”
“I am sorry for leaving you behind. I am stronger with all of you at
my side,” said the older brother. “If we stick together, we can
overcome anything.”
“I was wrong. The best way to learn about the Grimm is by
fighting them,” said the younger sister.
“I was the biggest fool of all, and I hope you can forgive me,” said
the younger brother. “I was so selfish, I lost sight of the most
important things in life.”
The family hugged, forgiving one another for their mistakes.
“Father was killed because he was fighting the Grimm alone,” the
younger sister said. “We work much better as a team.”
They all agreed. For the rest of their days, the hunter’s children
defended the new village they built together, and welcomed anyone
seeking refuge from the Grimm. And often over the years, the
siblings ventured out into the world to offer help wherever they could,
inspiring others with their bravery, heart, wisdom, and humility.

This is one of my favorite fairy tales, and I include it here not only
because its messages still resonate today—perhaps more than ever
—but also because the hunter’s four children bear a striking
resemblance to the four-student teams at each of our Huntsmen
academies. One wonders if the king of Vale had this story in mind
when he established them after the Great War. While we do not
know the exact origin of this tale, it certainly predates the earliest
notions of Huntsmen and Huntresses as we now know them—as
hunters of Grimm.
The hunter’s children also embody many of the traits that make
for a good Huntsman, and in my experience, I can vouch for the
effectiveness of teamwork in overcoming any obstacle. I have also
wondered over the years if the lessons learned by each of the
children might also serve as a guide for leaders of Vale, Vacuo,
Mistral, and Atlas. Surely four kingdoms, working together, can
accomplish more than each of them alone.

Once upon a time, there was a very wise king. Every morning, he
opened the gates of his castle to the people of his kingdom and held
an open court, where the people could ask for advice, make formal
complaints, or petition for his help. The only requirement for seeking
an audience with the king was that afterward you had to do whatever
he directed.
“My neighbor’s tree fell on my fence and broke it,” one man
reported. “Half of the tree is still lying on my property! Who should
pay to remove it and repair my fence?”
“That’s an easy one,” the king said. “The half of the tree that lies
on your property now belongs to you. You will cut up the tree
together and both of you will use the wood to rebuild your fence. Sell
the remaining wood and split the profits evenly.”
“Sounds fair,” said the man. “Thank you, Your Grace.”
“I’m not finished,” said the king. “Use your portion of the sales to
purchase a new tree and plant it with your neighbor in place of the
one they lost.”

The man sighed, but the king was very wise.
On another day, a sad woman in tattered clothes approached the
king. “Your Grace,” she said. “Creatures of Grimm destroyed my
village. My family is dead. Everything I’ve ever cared about is gone.”
“I’m very sorry for your loss.” The king stepped down from his
throne and clasped the hands of the forlorn widow. “What is your
question?” he asked softly.
“What should I do now?”
He studied her face for a long while. He smiled sadly. “You must
keep living.”
The widow had no choice but to listen to his advice. And the king
was not only wise, but generous.
“Please stay in the castle and take what time you need to grieve,”
said the king. “When you’re ready, come to me and ask your
question again.”
An attendant led the widow to her quarters, gave her new clothes
and a warm meal, and left her alone. For many weeks, the widow did
nothing but sleep, eat, and cry, but eventually she took new interest
in the life of the court, and particularly in the kindly king. For the next
six months, she rose each morning and went to his court to watch
him dole out advice and justice. The widow admired his steady
gentleness and perception. He always saw the truth of a situation,
and he listened not only to people’s words but also to their hearts.
It happened that the king’s grateful subjects sometimes brought
him offerings, from food they had prepared to livestock or precious
jewels and gold. The king, ever humble, always encouraged others
to give to those truly in need, but he was also gracious and polite. It
didn’t hurt to accept their gifts and then donate them to a good cause
himself. One day, a man with wild eyes arrived with a burlap sack
that held a gift for the king. When it was his turn to speak, he pulled
a silver crown from the sack.
“Please take this, My Grace,” the man said.
“Thank you, but I already have a crown,” the king replied.
“Not like this one. Believe me, you will be doing me a favor by
taking it. It does me no good, and as the wisest king in the land, you
are the only one suited to wear it.”

The king demurred. “You flatter me,” he said.
But the man insisted. “Allow me to come closer and I’ll explain.”
Finally, the king gestured the man forward. As the guards
watched anxiously, the man leaned in and whispered in the king’s
ear. The king raised an eyebrow.
“How came you to have this?” the king asked.
“That doesn’t matter. Will you accept?”
“Very well. It’s a hard offer to refuse, and you have made me
The king allowed the man to place the crown on his head. It fit
him perfectly, and he closed his eyes.
A moment later, the king snatched the crown from his head and
leapt from his seat. His face was pale as the moon.
“What is this?” he cried. “Guards! Seize that man!”
But the man had disappeared.
“Find him,” the king spluttered. He collapsed back into his throne
and turned the crown over and over in his hands. “It can’t be true,”
he muttered.
Then he placed the crown back on his head and stared off into
the distance.
“Your Grace?” an attendant asked. “There are still a dozen
supplicants seeking audience.”
The king would not respond, and the attendants dismissed them,
along with the entire court. “Sorry,” they said. “It’s best to come back
As they were led out of the chamber, the widow glanced back at
the king on the throne. His brow was furrowed in concentration.
The next morning, the king wandered into court late, for the first
time that anyone could remember. Dark smudges under his bleary
eyes suggested he had not slept. Though the crown was nowhere to
be seen, the king was distracted and behaving oddly as he
entertained questions from the court.
“Your Grace,” a man said. “My daughter wants to marry her
childhood best friend, but he is the son of bakers. I had hoped she
would marry higher than her station. What should I do?”
The king shifted in his seat. “Are the boy’s parents good bakers?”

The man frowned. “I suppose so. Yes.”
“Then what more can you ask for? Let your daughter be happy,
and enjoy free bread.”
“I hadn’t thought of that. Thank you, Your Grace.”
A moment later the king waved the man back. “Wait a moment!
Perhaps I was wrong. A family requires more than bread. You should
follow your instincts and wait for a better match for your daughter.”
“What?” the widow said. She clapped her hands over her mouth,
but she wasn’t the only one who was surprised.
“All right. If you’re sure …” The man looked around the court in
“Of course I’m sure. I’m your king.” The king clapped. “Next!”
The court murmured.
“What’s wrong?” the widow asked a servant. “He’s never
changed his mind before.”
“Or given bad advice,” the servant added.
“So you agree that was bad advice?” the widow asked eagerly.
Suddenly nervous, the servant muttered,

“Of course not. He’s the king,” and hurried away.
The king continued to second-guess himself, his advice
increasingly erratic, until he jumped up and rushed out of the
chamber without even dismissing the court.
The next day was much the same, as was the next. A red crease
marked the king’s forehead, and he became ever more sullen and

Then one morning, the court was closed altogether.
“What’s going on?” the widow asked.
“The king is no longer accepting audiences with his subjects,” an
attendant answered.
“Is he all right?” the widow asked with concern.
“He is the king,” the attendant said.
The widow threw up her hands in exasperation. “What kind of an
answer is that?”
Soon the king’s court announced that he was seeking the wisest
philosophers in the land to consult with him. The person who helped
him would receive their heart’s desire. Would-be advisers flocked to
the castle for a chance to give the king advice for a change. The only
rule was that if they breathed a word about his dilemma, they would
be executed.
“That doesn’t sound like the king,” the widow said. “He is a good

“People change,” the king’s steward said.
“This all started with that crown,” the widow said. “Where is it?”
“Locked away in the bowels of the castle. He has the only key to
the room,” the steward said. “The king spends most of his time there.
It’s the first place he goes after speaking to these advisers of his.”
The steward sniffed. “He never even talks to me anymore.”
“What could make him so strange and paranoid?” the widow
asked. The question had been plaguing her.
“Even if I knew, I wouldn’t tell you,” the steward said. “On threat
of death.”
The widow wandered the lower levels of the castle until she
found the one door that was locked. She listened at the door but no
one was inside. She peered through the keyhole until she spied a
wooden chair with the crown upon it.
“That’s no throne for a king,” she murmured. She hid in the empty
room across from it and waited. She did not have to wait long. The

king had an audience with an adviser that morning, and he soon
came hurrying down to the room. He looked around suspiciously
before drawing a key from a chain around his neck and opening the
door. He closed it tightly behind him.
The widow crept up to the door and peered through the keyhole.
The king sat on the wooden chair, the crown on his head. His head
was bowed, as though the crown had grown too heavy for him to lift.
He murmured to himself, then suddenly pulled the crown from his
head and threw it across the room. He hurried over to pick it up and
then placed it back on the chair with care.
The widow took a deep breath. She stood and knocked on the
The door flew open. The king’s face was contorted with rage. He
seized her arm. “Who are you? What are you doing here?” He called
out to the hallway, “Guards!”
The widow raised a hand protectively. “Your Grace. Half a year
ago I came to you with a question.”
“I don’t remember,” he said.
She swallowed her disappointment.
“You told me to come back when I was ready and ask my
question again,” she said.
“I don’t give out advice anymore,” the king said, sighing. “I can
barely help myself.”
The widow’s voice was firm. “I am not here to ask for your
wisdom, but to offer some of my own. You called for people to come
and advise you on your problem. I am here to make my attempt.”
“You?” He shook his head, but she persisted.
“Tell me what’s troubling you. Whatever it is, it is too much for
one person to bear, and we need our king back.”
The king considered. Then he nodded. “This crown has shown
me a vision of a crossroads in my future. I will have an important
decision to make one day, and from what I can tell, an impossible
one. I can’t see my way to a favorable outcome. This has never
happened to me before.”
“Not all outcomes are favorable, My Grace,” the widow said.

“I can’t accept that. This crown has given me time to figure it out.
To work out a solution.”
“This crown has burdened you with a problem that you are not
yet able to handle. That perhaps you will never be able to handle. In
the meantime, it has paralyzed you with indecision. Even if you come
up with an answer, you will have more time to wonder if it’s the
correct one. If such a thing exists.”
The king frowned.
“If you can’t make simple decisions now—whether a girl should
marry a baker or if two people claiming ownership of the same pig
should divide it in two—then how will you respond when the moment
of decision finally comes? If it ever comes?” The widow picked up
the crown. “This is no gift. It is a curse.”
“What should I do?” the king asked.
The widow smiled. “You must keep living.”
The king collapsed into the rickety old seat. “That’s good advice.”
He sighed.
“You gave me that advice. But you also gave me more than that.
You gave me my life. Hope for a future. And soon afterward …” Her
face flushed. “A reason for living.”
She held up the crown. “May I?”
He held up a hand. “You don’t want to do that.”
“You’ll forgive me if just this once I ignore your excellent wisdom.”
She placed the crown on her head.
The widow saw a future moment, a decision posed by the man
before her. Only he seemed different than he did now—happier. And
he looked at her differently than he did now. He asked her a
question. She didn’t need any time to consider her answer.
“Yes,” she breathed.
“‘Yes’ what?” the kng asked when she removed the crown.
“Let’s wait and discover that question together,” she said. “I
imagine my vision was rather different from yours.”
“Excuse me?” the king asked.
“Forget it.” She placed the crown on the ground and resisted the
urge to stomp on it. “If you want my honest advice, I would lock this
crown in here and throw away the key. Put it out of your mind. Live

your life, and trust in yourself to make the right decision when the
moment comes, with all the information you have at hand.” She
shrugged. “Or allow yourself to make the wrong decision, comforted
in the knowledge that you tried your very best. In either case, the
future is one of your own making.”
The king smiled. “Allow myself to make a mistake?”
She took his hand and pulled him to his feet. “Just as you gave
me permission to go on living, even when my life had changed
forever.” “I think I do remember you,” he said again.
“Good,” she said. It was a start.
Once upon a time, there was a very wise king. And an even wiser

This is just one example of many fairy tales that feature magical
items that can help or harm their owners—or maybe both at the
same time. These are usually cautionary tales, demonstrating that
the curtain separating good and evil is thin indeed. They also
underscore an unfortunate but all too common truth: Bad things
sometimes happen to good people.
We all acknowledge that knowledge is power, but the wise king in
this story learns, with a little help, that too much knowledge can
make you powerless. Whether you are dealing with knowledge,
power, or a mystical artifact, what matters most is what you choose
to do with it. Or what you don’t choose.
Even the darkest stories may offer comfort, and I find the
message of this tale somewhat uplifting: No matter what life deals
you, no matter how hard the decisions you must face, keep living.

Go on, I double-dare you,” Poppy said. She nudged her younger
brother, Oak, toward the forest edge. But he planted his feet and
refused to budge.
“Mother and Father forbid us from entering the woods,” Oak said
Poppy threw up her hands. “Oh, it isn’t dangerous. You’re just a
coward.” She saw no need to worry about her parents’ rules.
“I want to go home,” Oak whimpered, his lips trembling.
She retorted, “It’s perfectly safe! Look, I’ll go in first.” So she did.
Poppy darted into the forest, ignoring Oak’s wailing. She didn’t go
far, though. She slipped behind a thick tree trunk and watched her
brother cry. He huddled on the ground not ten feet away, arms
around his knees as he rocked back and forth, screaming her name.
“Poppy! Poppy! Poppy!”
The coward wasn’t even going to come after her to see if she
was all right. He was utterly useless, she thought.

Then suddenly Oak stopped yelling. Poppy could still see him,
but he had gone quiet. When she looked behind her, the hairs on the
back of her neck rose and the shadows seemed somehow closer.
She ran out of the forest, but she shoved her shaking hands into her
pockets and put on a broad smile when she reached her brother.
“Told you so. Not a single Grimm! Now it’s your turn,” Poppy said,
taunting him.
Oak looked up, wet lines streaking the dirt on his face. Why was
he always so dirty?
“I don’t want to,” he said, pouting.
But Poppy insisted. “It’s only fair. I went first, now you have to go.
If you don’t, I won’t be your friend. I won’t play with you anymore.”
“You have to be my friend,” Oak said.
“I have to be your sister. It isn’t the same thing,” Poppy said. “I
have other friends. Lots of other friends.”
He hated when she played with them and left him behind. So
Oak pulled himself to his feet and gave her a miserable look. “Please
don’t make me,” he moaned.
Poppy crossed her arms. Oak sighed and trudged toward the
forest, dragging his feet and slowing down as he reached the first
line of trees. He turned back once, and Poppy made a shooing
motion. Then he walked into the forest until the darkness swallowed
Poppy waited for Oak to shriek and run out again. He had always
had an active imagination, fueled by occasional accounts of Grimm
attacks in Vale. He often woke her up at night, crying over bad
dreams. He wouldn’t last long inside the forest.
Poppy listened hard for him, but the forest was so silent it was
almost unsettling. It was getting dark and cold and their parents
would be expecting them home soon. Oak had seemingly vanished.
He’s probably just hiding like I did, Poppy thought as she
approached the forest once again. He copies everything I do.
This time, crossing into the dark web of trees felt like crossing
into another world. It was already night here, and the air itself
seemed to be breathing all around her. Poppy’s skin crawled as she
went deeper and deeper into the forest. In the gloom she could

barely make out a trail worn into the grass and dirt, or perhaps faded
and overgrown with time. Would Oak have walked here? Suddenly
she was unsure.
She nearly tripped over him, a lump in the path. He was huddled
over like before, head down, arms wrapped around his knees.
Poppy nearly yelled at him, but instead she crouched and put a
hand over his. It was ice-cold. He was only a little boy.
“I’m sorry,” she said softly. “I shouldn’t have made you. Let’s go
At the word “home,” Oak lifted his head. His face was as pale as
Grimm bone. He had to be frightened out of his mind, Poppy
realized, and she felt a flash of sympathy. She took his hand, helped
him up, and led him back the way they’d come.
Her brother was unusually quiet, probably either in shock or
sulking, she thought. He gripped her hand tightly in his, fingers
digging into her flesh like he would die if he let go, but his skin never
By the time she got him inside their house, she was really
worried. His eyes were glassy and sunken in his pale face, the skin
around them bruised like he hadn’t been sleeping. Before their
parents spotted him, Poppy hurried Oak to their room and explained
that he wasn’t feeling well. Mother and Father were angry that they
were back so late, but also relieved to see them. Poppy was thankful
they would never know that she and Oak had defied their wishes.
She had a cold supper and followed Oak to bed as soon as she
could. He was only a round shape under the covers now. When the
mound twitched, Poppy said, “Shhhh … Go back to sleep.” Then,
more quietly she added, “I’m sorry about before. I love you.”
In the middle of the night, Poppy woke in a cold sweat. Screams
echoed in her head, remnants of a forgotten nightmare. She looked
at Oak’s bed, but his sheets were twisted in a heap on the floor. He
was gone.
Poppy slipped out of bed, stepped out of her room, and tiptoed
softly through the house, listening for Oak. Her parents’ bedroom
door was open, and Poppy was relieved. Oak must have gone in

there to sleep, which he often did when he woke in the night. Poppy
crept to the door and peered in. Her parents were sitting up in bed.
Poppy walked in. “Mother? Father?” Her voice was dry and raspy,
almost a whisper. Had she caught a chill in the forest? Her parents
didn’t respond, so she drew closer. Then she fell back in horror when
she saw their faces.
Their mouths gaped and their lifeless eyes were wide open.

Their skin had turned as pale as bone. She couldn’t bring herself to
touch them, but she knew they would be cold as the Solitas tundra.

Poppy huddled on the floor of their room, knees to her chest,
paralyzed with fear.
After she had calmed herself, Poppy stood up. She still had to
find her brother. “Oak!” she called, passing from room to room. He
wasn’t there. The front door was open, though, and she went
through it into the freezing night. “Oak!”
It was well after midnight, but lights were on next door at the
home of her best friend, Lorimar. She walked up to the house and let
herself in. Lorimar’s parents lay on the ground in the kitchen in the
same state as her own parents: white skin, blank eyes. With growing
dread, Poppy entered Lorimar’s room, where they had been playing
cards just the morning before.
Oak was there, slumped over Lorimar’s bed, but Poppy’s friend
was missing.
Oak’s hair was now as white as his skin, and red lines radiated
up his neck and down his arms. He was cold to the touch. How had
he gotten here, and where was her friend?

Poppy felt too numb to weep. She left the house and
mechanically went to the next one on the street, where she found a
similar scene. Everyone dead. She went to the next, and the next.
Five houses down she found Lorimar’s body, and another missing
child, an older girl named Lily. Lily’s body turned up at Dijon’s house,
but Dijon was absent. By dawn, when Poppy had reached the very
last house, she knew she was in a ghost town, only she felt like the
ghost. And she had a theory.
She no longer felt anything when she found more bodies,
identical to the others. She only felt curiosity and fear when she
didn’t find Dijon’s body. He was out there somewhere, perhaps still in
town looking for more victims. What if Poppy was the last person
alive? She had to leave.

She hurried back to her house to pack her things. To say goodbye to her dead family and her home. To say she was sorry for
bringing this nightmare on all of them, for bringing it back from the
forest, because she was certain it was all her fault. She had goaded
her brother into trespassing in the woods, and now she knew he had
died there. The thing she had led home with her had been wearing
Oak’s shape, hiding in his body or controlling it, and waiting to kill the
next people who came into its path. Poppy had heard of Grimm that
could possess objects like Geists, but possessing Humans?
Children? Anything was possible where the darkest of evil was
Poppy avoided looking at her parents’ room as she returned to
her own. She flung open her closet, but her suitcase wasn’t there
and she was overcome with a sense of dread. Suddenly she
remembered her own time in the forest, when she was peering out at
her brother from the trees. Had she herself come close to being
possessed? She had felt a malevolent presence in the forest, after
all. She had seen shadows moving in. She had escaped, but Oak
had taken her place.
Why not me? she wondered. Why had the Grimm possessed
Oak, left her alone, killed her parents, and moved on to Lorimar?
Poppy remembered where she had left her suitcase. It was under
the bed! She knelt down and reached for it, groping around until her
hands closed around—
Something cold.
She lurched back. No.
Forget the suitcase, forget her things. She had to go. Now.
Instead, Poppy slowly lifted the covers that dangled to the floor.
Leaned down and peered under.
There was a body.
She swallowed and reached and dragged it out. She already
knew who it was, who it had to be. And she knew what that had to
She left Dijon’s body there on the floor, and went to the
bathroom. She looked in the mirror and saw her own face. Only it
wasn’t her face anymore.

Her long hair was as white as the snow on a mountaintop, her
face as stark as a blank page. Dark veins crept toward her large,
black eyes, matching the veins twining her pale arms. She was no
longer Poppy. She was dead. She was now a demon.
Perhaps in gratitude, or maybe to torment her with the full
knowledge of what she had started the moment she defied her
parents and sent her brother into the woods, the Grimm had saved
Poppy for last.

The tragic tale of Poppy and Oak is one of the most well-known in
this collection, as it has inspired dozens of horror novels, films,
comic books, and even video games. Though the names of the
characters often change with each telling—thus the use of the more
traditional title, “The Grimm Child”—this story has become a staple
around campfires and at bedtime. (It is also known to be a special
favorite of parents with disobedient children.) Although some of its
edginess may have worn off, it continues to serve as a cautionary
tale, even for those quick to dismiss it as a children’s story. For as
with most of the fables in this collection, it contains a grain of truth,
and perhaps more than just a grain.
The type of Grimm that Poppy encounters does exist and is
popularly called the Chill, at least by the seasoned Huntsmen I have
consulted. No matter where this story appears, in whatever form, it
always includes some variation on the line “She must have caught a
chill in the forest.” Whether this line informed the name of the real-life
Grimm or vice versa is unknown, but in some written accounts the
word is in fact capitalized. Chills are not restricted to hopping from
child to child, however—they can possess anyone with the slightest
touch. The good news is, they are only found in shadows, and
almost always travel alone.

Perhaps you have played the old party game The Chill, in which
players must attempt to discover the Grimm in their midst before it is
too late, the idea being that a Human possessed by the Chill is
indistinguishable from an unpossessed Human. However, you may
be relieved to know that a Chill in a Human host cannot speak or act
normally, the way that Poppy does. If someone has been taken over
by a Chill, you would know it immediately; they cannot speak, or
perhaps they will only repeat the same word, over and over again—
the last word the Human spoke. Moreover, Chills cannot control a
Human body for more than a few minutes, making it impossible for
them to kill an entire town in one night. They rely on the element of
surprise and the unwillingness of most people to kill a friend or loved
one until they are certain they are already lost. Small comfort
perhaps, for if you are ever unfortunate enough to encounter one,
you likely will not survive to tell the tale.
Another important note: The descriptions of the possessed
children and dead townspeople in the original tale do not include the
white skin and hair or the black eyes. So where did the white hair
and skin come from, and why did I choose that particular description
for this collection? I believe that over the years some versions of this
story have been conflated with another fairy tale about a white witch
in the woods, which bears other striking resemblances to “The
Grimm Child.” Purists may resist my decision not to separate the
traditional tales, but this is a case in which the popular version is so
familiar and beloved that it has become almost canon. It also fits with
our natural inclination to expect and hope that evil will be easy to
recognize, rather accepting that evil can lurk behind any face. Alas,
we are often slowest to see that darkness within ourselves.

Many, many years ago, in a faraway land, there was a war between
Humans and animals.
Humans envied animals because of all the amazing things they
could do: They could run faster than a rumor spreads, see in
darkness as if it were daylight, and wield the strength of three people
at once. All that, and they were never troubled by the Creatures of
Grimm, which sought only to destroy Humans and their creations.
The Humans’ envy soon turned into hatred.
Yet animals also envied Humans because of all the amazing
things they could do. Humans could use Dust to perform miracles;
they could adapt to any situation; and they could build structures,
machines, tools—and weapons. All that, and they persisted in the
face of constant adversity and tragedy brought by the Creatures of
Grimm. The animals’ envy soon turned into fear.
As the war raged on, there were many casualties on both sides.
At night, animals raided the Human village and took whatever they

needed to survive. During the day, Humans hunted animals in the
One day, a god was passing through the land when they
happened upon a bloody fight between the Humans and the animals.
They froze everyone in place and walked onto the battlefield.
“Why are you fighting?” the god asked. Their words were
understandable to both species, who did not understand each
other’s language and had never tried to learn. The god released one
Human and one animal to answer.
The Human and the animal eyed the god suspiciously. They had
two arms and two legs like a Human, but also branching horns like
an animal.
“Are you Human or animal?” the animal asked.
“I am neither and both,” the god said. “Why are you fighting?”
“They are not like us,” the Human and the animal said, pointing at
each other. Little did they know that they had spoken the same
words. Fear of those different from you is a universal language.
“Why must everyone be the same?” the god asked them.
“We worry about what they might do to us,” the Human and
animal said.
“So you have something in common, after all.” The god crossed
their arms. “Judge not what others might do, but by what you see
them do.”
“Humans are as capable of destruction as they are of creation,”
the animal said. “Evil is in their hearts.”
“Animals are so much stronger than us, but they will not join us in
fighting the Grimm,” the Human retorted.
“Have you tried working together?” the god asked.
“Yes,” the animal said. “But the Humans wanted to control us and
make us their property so they can sacrifice our lives against the
Grimm instead of their own. But that is not our fight! We just want to
be free.”
“Yes,” the Human said. “But the animals are wild and unruly.
They steal from us at night. We only want to keep them in their place
so we may live in safety and peace.”

“You have grown to see only the worst in one another,” the god
said. “But you are more alike than you realize. Your potential is
unlimited if you can only learn to celebrate one another’s best
qualities and embrace your differences.”
The god looked around and soon the larger group of Humans
and animals could move again. Each side regarded the other
“I can end this conflict if you all agree to subject yourselves to my
judgment,” the god said. “If you do not agree to live in peace, you will
kill one another off, and perhaps destroy the world in the process.”
The Humans and animals considered carefully. The Humans saw
themselves in the god’s speech and manner and were certain the
god would side with them. The animals noted the god’s magnificent
horns, so they assumed the god would side with them.
“We choose life,” the Humans and animals said at the same time.
“We accept your judgment, O Wise One.”
“So be it,” the god said. Suddenly a thick fog rolled onto the
battlefield. The Humans and animals called out in panic when they
were unable to see one another, still worried that the other side
would attack. When the fog finally dissipated, the god was gone—
and the Humans and animals were also gone, for when they could
see one another again, they could see that both sides had changed.
The animals had gained Human features and stood upright on two
legs, while the Humans had gained animal features and enhanced
senses. Though they all now looked alike, they also were different
from one another: Some had the ears of a cat, some the horns of a
bull. Some had sharp tusks while others had long tails. Some had
strong scales or spikes, some had fins or wings.
“What have you done to us?” they all cried.
“I thought the god was going to judge which of us was superior,”
one person complained.
“Maybe they have,” said one of the animals. “Were you Human or
animal before?”
“I don’t think it matters anymore,” the person admitted.
If you looked closely, you could tell who had been Human,
because of the way they stroked their new fur and lifted their eyes to

try to glimpse their new horns or held their hands up to admire their
new claws.
You could tell who had been animal, because of the way they
stumbled and fell on two legs like a newborn, poked at their bare
flesh, and pressed their fingers clumsily against their rows of flat
teeth. Also, they had no clothes, and they were astonished to feel a
strange new emotion—embarrassment—although the idea of
dressing up like Humans had never occurred to them before.
“I can see so far!”
“Look at how much I can lift!”
“I have hands!”
“I’m walking on two feet like a monkey!”
Those who had been Human shared their own cloaks and jackets
with those who needed coverings.
Finally one of them said what they all could see and feel. “It
seems we are neither Human nor animal.”
The whole crowd had the same question. “Then what are we?”
“Better than both,” one suggested.
The god had created the first Faunus, combining the best parts of
both Humans and animals so they could live in peace together. But
that is not the end of the story—rather, it is only the beginning.
Solving one problem often creates new ones to deal with, and the
Faunus would not live happily ever after. Instead of warring with one
another based on jealousy and fear, they would still fight with one
another—over matters of philosophy instead of appearance.
As the Faunus acclimated to their new forms and to their new kin,
Creatures of Grimm approached the former battlefield stealthily—
drawn by the heightened emotions and confusion of the fledgling
beings. Those who had been animals were unconcerned at first, as
the Grimm had never bothered with them before, but they soon
discovered that Grimm were as interested in Faunus as they were in
Delighting in and emboldened by their newfound strength and
agility, creativity and adaptiveness, the Faunus engaged the Grimm
in combat. But they were still uncertain in their bodies, unfamiliar in
the ways of Aura and Semblances. They took heavy losses against

the Grimm, and it was a terrible blow to be cut down before finding
their destiny as a new race. Horrified and afraid, the Faunus beat a
hasty retreat to the local village. But there they received a poor
welcome and faced yet another hurdle.
The villagers closed their doors and their hearts to the strangers,
alarmed by their appearance. “We live here,” cried some of the
Faunus who had previously been Human. “Don’t you remember us?”
“We don’t know you,” cried the villagers, their faces stony and
their voices cold. “We don’t trust you. Begone!”
“Were we so narrow-minded when we were Human?” asked a
Faunus who had been so.
“Yes,” replied the rest.
The Faunus had changed so much, inside and outwardly, so that
they were no longer recognizable to their mothers and fathers,
sisters and brothers, sons and daughters. In addition, they had been
pursued by Creatures of Grimm, which the villagers viewed as an
intentional attack. In the chaos that followed, the Faunus and
Humans all fled for their lives. The Humans left to find a new
settlement, safe from Grimm and closed to Faunus. The Faunus left
to find somewhere they could live peacefully with one another and
become the best versions of themselves, free of prejudice.
Since they were born, Faunus have never stopped running from
Grimm and Humans, and searching for a place to call home.

While this Faunus creation story is just as based in myth as “The
Shallow Sea,” it contains no less truth; in fact, here the truth lies
much closer to the surface.
If the former is a popular bedtime story for Faunus children, this
more somber and didactic tale often takes its place as they come
into adulthood and learn the harsh realities of the world and FaunusHuman relations. Unsurprisingly, Faunus always cast their god as a
wise and noble figure, while Human stories portray the same god as
a trickster, not to be trusted. Rather telling, isn’t it? Notably, many
Faunus fairy tales are open-ended like this one, and it’s uncommon
to find any that offer what anyone might characterize as a “happily
ever after.” Quite the contrary: Faunus stories tend to be bittersweet
or downright depressing.
If you are familiar with the classic novel The Thief and the
Butcher (or have seen the excellent film adaptation), you might
recognize a common theme in Faunus literature—much of it reflects
the Faunus’ belief that their story is still unfolding and they have yet
to discover their true purpose. This is a fascinating and dare I say
comforting notion, the idea that we are all the heroes of our stories
and that we have yet to make our greatest achievements. I trust that

we all will have an important role to play in our shared destiny,
Faunus not least among us.

There once was a man.
This man was said to be very powerful. Some claimed that he
could perform magic like a god. Some even claimed that he himself
was a god, but he was always the first to deny it: “I am only a man.
Not even a very good one,” he said.
One day, this man happened upon a village under attack by
Creatures of Grimm. Most people would hasten past and be glad of
their own good fortune, but though he was only a man, he was
certainly unlike most people. Instead of quickening his pace and
continuing his journey, he entered the village, drawn toward
panicked cries for help that may as well have been calling his name.
It was a mistake. But it was not his first, and it would not be his
This man stood alone against an army of evil monsters. When
the battle was over, every last Grimm in the village had been
eradicated, and the man was utterly spent. Four survivors cautiously

emerged from their hiding places, wondering how they had been
saved. They found the man, unconscious but alive, and nursed him
back to health.
He awoke four days later. “Thank you for saving us, stranger,”
they greeted him. “But how did you defeat all those Grimm by
The man said simply, “I have been at this a very long time.”
“You could have died!”
“I likely would have, if not for you.”
They were surprised. “But we’re the reason you got hurt in the
first place.”
“Were you? Well then, I guess we’re even.”
“But you didn’t have to stop to save us.”
“Of course I did. I was here when no one else could help. Why
did you stay behind to take care of me?”
“Because we were here, and you needed us.”
The man smiled. “And thus the circle is complete.”
“I saw what you did!” A little girl stepped forward, staring at the
man with wide eyes. “I was hiding and I saw. You waved your stick,
and the monsters turned to ash.”
Her adult companions laughed. “She’s been going on about this
for days. We were hoping you could set her straight.”
“It’s true,” she cried. Tears filled her eyes and her voice shook.
“They blew away.”
“Now don’t tell lies,” the adults berated the girl.
“Do not be so quick to dismiss the words of the young,” the man
said, smiling kindly at the girl. He hesitated a moment, then added,
“Especially when they speak the truth.”
The villagers were confused. “No Dust can do something like that
to Grimm,” they said.
“No Dust can,” the man agreed.
“Then it must have been magic, and you must be a god.”
He held up his hands. “I am only a man. Not even a very good
“How can you say that after risking your life for strangers?”

“I’m trying to be a better man.” He closed his eyes and appeared
to sleep, so the others left him alone to rest. They had more
questions than before, but those could wait until morning.
That night, the man crept out of the village. Soon, he realized he
was being followed. It was the four villagers he had rescued, along
with the girl.
“What do you want?” the man asked.
“We want to be more like you,” one of the villagers said. “Maybe
we can’t learn to do the amazing things you can, but we can learn to
The man was moved, and yet he protested. “I travel alone,” he
“Aren’t you lonely?” asked the girl.
The man was lonely indeed, and the girl reminded him of his own
family, long gone.
She smiled. “You don’t have to be alone anymore.” Then she
repeated his own words back to him: “‘Do not be so quick to dismiss
the words of the young.’”
“Especially when they speak the truth,” he added, shaking his
head. “You are a quick learner.” He agreed to let them accompany
him, for a little while at least. Until they found a new village where
they could settle or he could leave them behind without being
It was a mistake. And it would not be his last.
The group journeyed together for four years, and in that time,
they were joined by more people they’d rescued from Grimm. Word
traveled faster than they did, and soon others began seeking them
out. Some wanted to learn from the man. Some wanted to be safe.
And some just wanted to become part of something bigger than
themselves. When people whispered rumors about the man and his
followers, they called them the Circle: a fellowship of people
committed to learning from, and helping, others for the benefit of all.
“A new group just arrived, from southern Esker,” said the girl—
now a young woman. “Seven men, nine women, and four children.”
“What do they want?” asked the man.
“They want to join your Circle, of course.”

He rolled his eyes. “My Circle. But it was your idea to call us
“People need a name to rally around, and since you won’t give us
yours …”
“I have had many names—”
“So you’ve said.”
He sighed. “This is a dangerous path. I have never wanted
She was startled. “Is that all we are to you?” she asked. “I
thought we were your friends. I thought you were our family.”
His voice softened. “You are that. But I have made terrible
mistakes that hurt both those close to me and strangers alike. Those
who follow me are likely to find regret or worse. Particularly my …
“You know, it’s talk like that, your humility and unwillingness to
lead, that makes people want to follow you. Ironic, isn’t it?” she
pointed out.
He smiled wryly. “I was thinking more along the lines of
“We follow you because we love you and want to learn from you.
You are always saying our future depends on people coming
together. That is exactly what you are accomplishing here.”
“What we are accomplishing here,” the man said. “You call me
your savior, when in truth it is you who saved me.”
The young woman blushed. “That’s what your teachings are all
about. If we can’t save ourselves, we have to save one another. Life
is a circle, is it not?”
The man laughed. “The student becomes the master. It’s also
annoying when you throw my words back at me.”
“That’s why I do it,” she said.
“But you’re right, as usual. We need to teach as many people as
we can to defend themselves, and protect one another, against the
Grimm. And from worse things they might face.”
“What could be worse than the Grimm?” she asked.
“I hope you never find out,” he said.

Not long after this, the man was poisoned by someone in his own
group. When the traitor was discovered, he hissed, “We have heard
that the man cannot die. I wanted to see if that was true.”
The young woman wanted to execute the traitor, but from his
deathbed the man intervened. “Let him go, that he may tell others
the truth: I am just a man. And not even—” A cough kept him from
“A very good one,” the young woman said. She let the traitor go.
“Isn’t there anything you can do, with all your powers?” the young
woman asked the man. “Can’t you save yourself?”
She leaned forward. “You told us that your life is a circle and you
have lived other lives before this one. That you have had many
names. Does that mean that the traitor was right?”
“I talk too much,” he whispered.
“So it’s true?”
His voice was so low she strained to hear it. “I have never lied to
you. But sometimes we make our own truths. We believe what we
want to believe, or what we need to believe.”
“If you weren’t already dying, I would kill you myself. If everything
you’ve said is true, you must promise to come back to me. Come
back to us,” she begged.
“I can’t promise that.”
She stroked his forehead, comforting but also cajoling. “All right,
all right,” she said. “But come back anyway.”
When the man died, the Circle mourned him for four days and
four nights. But they carried on together and continued spreading the
lessons he had taught them. When he did return in a new life and
body, he was moved by all they had accomplished. He revealed
himself to their leader, now a middle-aged woman.
It was a mistake. And it would not be his last.
“It’s really you! You came back!” the woman said.
“You didn’t believe me until now?” he asked, disappointed.
“You have to admit, even with everything I saw you do,
immortality sounded farfetched.”
She caught the man up on all he had missed: The Circle had
settled and founded its own town, but they still sent people out to

help others and sometimes they brought back new members. Circle
was renowned as the only place with formal training in defense
against the Grimm, mastering Aura, and unlocking Semblances. It
was said that they created gods among men.
The man described his journey back, as he had traveled much in
the way he always had. But he had heard about the Circle
everywhere he went, and finally he had to see it for himself. As he
spoke to the woman, an audience gathered, and soon word spread
throughout the Circle that the founder had returned.

The man rose to leave, but the woman protested and asked him to
stay. He had built Circle, and they needed him.
“You clearly do not,” he said, gesturing to the village around
them. “You did all this without me. This movement has taken on a life

of its own.”
“We didn’t do this without you,” the woman argued. “You were the
foundation for everything, and your presence will make us even
The others cheered in agreement. The man considered. He had
wanted to bring people together, and his efforts were finally bearing
fruit. The accidental experiment was working, far better than any
attempts he had planned in his previous lifetimes.
“The people here believe in magic, though many have never
seen it,” she said. “If you show everyone that it’s real, that the man
with infinite lifetimes has returned as he promised—”
“I never promised,” the man said. “And any charlatan can show
them magic, if that’s all they’re interested in.”
She shook her head. “We trust in you and the fate you’ve laid out
for us. We believe in the good of people and our shared
responsibility to protect one another and Remnant. So many have
heard our stories about you, but now you’re here, in the flesh. Your
presence is living proof that everything you’ve said is true. It
reinforces our beliefs and commitment to the Circle. Together, now,
we will make ready for the final judgment.”
“It would be a mistake for me to stay,” he said.
“But not your first,” she said, “and probably not your last. Lead us
again! Where else are you needed more than here? Even a man
with infinite lives has his limits.”
She smiled, and he saw the girl he had met years ago, in another
life. “The burden doesn’t have to be yours alone anymore,” she said.
“But think of what we can pass down to the generations that follow.”
The man relented and rejoined his people. And for a time, all that
the woman had said seemed to come true. Many more followers
flocked to Circle and their reputation and message spread all
throughout Remnant. This was what he was here for, he thought.
Perhaps, in the end, he would be able to rest.
And then everything changed.
Circle was invaded. Not by a group of Grimm this time, but by a
group of warriors who stormed into the town and began attacking
men, women, and children alike. The townspeople fought back

valiantly, but the warriors were so strong that even with so many
against so few, the Circle was losing. Many of them were injured
before the man was summoned.
“Stop!” the man called. “What do you want here?”
A warrior stepped forward and grinned. She brandished a pair of
large swords. “I came here to fight a god.”
“I am just a man, and not even a very good one.”
“That’s not what I hear. Don’t you use magic? Do you die and
come back to life? That’s a god.”
“I can’t help what you’ve heard about me.” The man shot the
woman a pointed look. “But in my experience, gods are far less than
the stories told about them. I assure you, I am no god, and I don’t
want to fight you.”
“You don’t have a choice,” the warrior said.
“We always have a choice. We can choose to help others instead
of hurting them. We can choose how we want to live, and how we
want to die.” The man looked around at the people who had grown
close to him. “But we also must accept the consequences of our
“Here’s your choice, then. Fight me, or we will kill everyone here.”
“If I win, you will leave?” the man asked.
“The fight is to the death. If you win, my people will take my body
and go,” the warrior said.
“And if I lose?”
“We’ll take your body and go.”
“And you will leave my people alone?” the man asked. “You give
your word?”
The warrior nodded.
“Very well. I accept,” the man said.
“No!” the woman cried. “Don’t do this.”
The man took her hands. “If I die, it’s just a minor inconvenience.
If you die, our future dies with you.”
The man turned away to face the warrior. In a moment, the two of
them were in combat. One of his opponent’s blades was infused with
purple Dust; each time her blade clashed against the man’s staff, it
unbalanced him for a moment. Her other sword used yellow Dust to

send jolts of lightning through him when their weapons touched. If he
tried to keep his distance, she fired powerful energy blasts at him,
endangering not only him but all his people. And when she brought
her weapons together, she was able to pull objects toward her. Thus,
after a short while, she was able to disarm him.
The man had other powers, and he was able to deliver a number
of blows against her even without his staff; but whether by
Semblance or purple Dust, her feet always remained firmly rooted to
the ground. No matter how hard he tried, he could not throw her or
knock her down.
“You see,” he said to his people, “any powerful Aura or
Semblance can make someone appear godlike.”
“I’m flattered, and impressed that you are teaching right up until
the end,” the warrior said, narrowing her eyes. “But I will still crush
She brought her swords together and the man became heavier.
Each step he tried to take toward her was a battle.
“Did someone send you to kill me?” he asked through gritted
“Your mere existence makes you a target.” Now the warrior
pressed him flat on his back on the ground. “Don’t hold back, old
man. Don’t you want to win?”
The man considered. This battle could rage for a long time, and
in the process many of his people might be hurt or killed. He cared
only about their lives and the future they could build; each of their
lives was precious, while his own was expendable. There was a
faster, easier way to end this conflict, and perhaps he had already
accomplished what he had set out to do. The Circle would carry out
his mission in his absence.
As the warrior brought both swords down in a killing move, the
man made a choice.
He made a mistake.
Years and years and years later, when the man returned, no
matter where he went and whom he asked, no one had ever heard
of him or the Circle. Except for one very old woman who seemed
somehow familiar, though her left arm and right eye were missing.

When he mentioned the Circle, recognition flickered on her face and
she studied his.
“The Circle has been gone a long time,” she said softly. “I’m all
that’s left. People came and attacked us and our ideals. Our leader
fought them, and lost. After he died, they slaughtered everyone in
the Circle. Except for me.”
“Why?” the man asked.
“Why did they destroy us? Or why did they leave me to tell the
tale? I’ve spent most of my life turning that question over and over in
my mind, and I believe the answer is the same: So that everyone
would know the folly of placing their hopes and faith in one man.”
She looked away. “Not even a very good man.”
The man knew that if she asked who he was, he would not be
able to lie to her, as painful as the truth would be. But she didn’t ask,
and that hurt even more.
Instead, she turned her back on him and hobbled away. And he
let her go.

Many leaders have risen up through Remnant’s history as false
gods or by seizing control. And often people point to “The Infinite
Man” as a cautionary tale of what can go wrong when you place too
much faith or power in one person—or at least they point to some
version of this story. Like the man who supposedly lived multiple
lives, there are many variations of this tale, which in some cases are
quite contradictory.
In fact, few stories have been told in so many different ways over
the years, or lend themselves so easily to being used as propaganda
pushing one agenda or another. In certain hands, the lesson here is
about the danger of following “weak” leaders or those who seem too
good to be true. Or it’s about the risk of putting others before
yourself. Or it’s about being careful not to place unrealistic
expectations on people. What does it mean to you?
This story reveals a different lesson for me whenever I read it, but
in general I have a less cynical take: I think it’s about the power of
belief and how it can move people to action, for good or for ill or for a
mixture of both. Trust is one of the most powerful forces in this world,
and it is not to be abused or dismissed. As the story is related here,
the “infinite man” placed his trust in the girl as much as she did in
him, and perhaps they set their expectations too high on both sides.
It’s only natural for us to want or need to believe in something higher
and bigger than ourselves. Some people still worship gods, while

others insist that we must be our own salvation. But the world
doesn’t work in absolutes, so why can’t it be both?
This rendition—in which the man indeed is everything he claims
to be—is the most romantic and, I think, balanced version of the
story, which I have cobbled together from a variety of differing
accounts in an effort to paint a larger and clearer picture, one that is
slightly more sympathetic to the man. He is alternately portrayed as
a hero or a fool—and again I say, why can’t it be both? Less
commonly, he is represented as the villain. In response, I offer
another interpretation for your consideration: Good intentions do not
always have good results. We are all fallible. We all make mistakes.
And forgiveness of those failures goes hand in hand with trust.
Although I have embellished this story slightly—attributing
motives to the man’s actions based on my own assumptions and,
admittedly, my own prejudices and belief that there is good in all of
us—no one who wasn’t there could know what really happened. And
even then, they would only have a small part of the story. Therefore,
I leave it to you to decide whether this man is worthy of forgiveness.
Truth itself is not an absolute, and everyone is free to make their
own choices.

In the beginning, a dragon traveled the universe in search of other
beings like himself. In all the realms and all the worlds, across every
plane of existence, he found no one and nothing else. Finally,
overcome with loneliness, the dragon decided to create a companion
with whom he could share the cosmos and eternity—an equal,
fashioned in his own image. Because even an all-powerful god
cannot make something from nothing, the dragon divided himself
and all his magic into two halves.
However, he destroyed himself in the act of creation. The old god
was no more; in his place were two brothers, a dragon of pure light,
and his shadow, a dragon of unfathomable darkness. They were new
gods with shared memories and complementary abilities—and each
thought that he was the original, and the other his copy. Though they
had distinct personalities and competing desires, they were still
connected and did not feel whole unless they were together. Since
they could not agree on where to go, they decided to create a world
for themselves. And as they were bored by the vast, lifeless

universe, they decided to populate that world with other living beings
to entertain them.
Whatever the God of Light created, the God of Darkness
mimicked in his own way. The God of Light fashioned a sun, while
his brother made a moon. The God of Light made a green continent
covered in lush trees, grasses, plants, and flowers—the God of
Darkness added barren deserts, rocky mountains, jagged crevasses
in the earth. The God of Light breathed life into animals to explore
the new world, while his brother birthed creatures of Grimm that
were but their dark reflections.
One day the God of Light approached his brother. “I have been
trying to create a beautiful world for us, but your creations spoil it.”

“Your creations are almost as dull as the unending void was,”
said the God of Darkness. “If this place is going to entertain us, we
need to make things lively.” With that, the God of Darkness brought

forth earthquakes and volcanoes that tore his brother’s continent
apart into smaller lands, boiled the oceans, rained fire and ash, and
wiped out all the living things. “Look how they run!” The God of
Darkness laughed. “Look how they die.”
Troubled, the God of Light did what he could to repair the
damage and rebuild the lost lives, but each time he did, the God of
Darkness invented some new catastrophe to destroy them—and
worse, make them suffer as they died. All while his dark nightmare
beasts multiplied and spread across the world.
“Brother,” said the God of Light one day. “Why do you take
pleasure in torturing and destroying my creations?”
The God of Darkness smiled. “You take so much joy in their
creation, I merely want you to be able to do more of it.”
“But they are living things. They have feelings, and you are
causing them pain.”
“They do not reason as we do. They don’t even know what they
are. They have no understanding of their past, nor do they plan for
their future. They are mere playthings for our amusement.”
It had started out that way, but the God of Light had grown
attached to all the different forms of life he had brought forth. In each
of the animals he made, from the insects to the whales, he saw a
small part of himself. Even gods cannot fashion something from
nothing, and the brothers had given much of their essence to their
creations. When his creations suffered, the God of Light felt some
measure of their agony.
The God of Light wanted his brother to see the world as he did,
to comprehend the responsibility that came with their immense
power. And so, he made a bold proposal:
“What if we create a new form of life together, one more capable
and fascinating than the animals and insects? We can make them
aware of what they are, and empower them to control and shape
their world.”
The God of Darkness was intrigued. “If they can think and
communicate as we do, they won’t be as predictable as the things
you’ve made before.”

“There is one condition, Brother,” said the God of Light. “If we
create these beings together, then we must share in any decisions
about their fate. You must promise not to wipe them out on a whim;
they must have the chance to find their own destiny and rule or ruin
this world we have made for them.”
The God of Darkness agreed, and they set to work.
Their joint creation required qualities that would set them apart
from the animals and raise them closer to the gods themselves. With
this goal in mind, each god prepared a gift for the new beings.
“I will give them knowledge of themselves and their world,” said
the God of Darkness. “So they can comprehend life and death, and
thus they will also know fear.”
The God of Light said, “And I will give them free will, the power to
decide what to do with that knowledge and choose their own place in
the world.”
And thus Humanity was born. Because they embodied the
essence of both brothers, Humans were capable of both creation
and destruction, with the freedom and knowledge to choose their
actions along a path of light or darkness.
For a time,